Posts tonen met het label Pieter Vermandere. Alle posts tonen
Posts tonen met het label Pieter Vermandere. Alle posts tonen

dinsdag 7 december 2010

The California Energy Crisis (2)


After Enron’s bankruptcy, a confidential memo surfaced in which Enron’s own lawyers admit that the company abused the rules, by manipulating the energy market. Also, the memo reveals the names of the strategies Enron used to exploit the California electricity market: ‘Wheel Out’, ‘Get Shorty’, ‘Fat Boy’, ‘Death Star’...

The ‘Death Star’ memo for instance literally states that “Enron gets paid for moving energy to relieve congestion without actually moving energy or relieving congestion". During his appeal, Skilling’s answer to all the questions concerning these memos would be: “The rules weren’t quite clear...”

Still, the question remains: Why did the traders act so unethical? The documentary draws a parallel with the well-known Milgram experiment. As Milgram found out, people lost their sense of morality when a supervisor says that behaving inhumanly -in this case giving higher electric shocks- is permitted.

It’s obvious that Skilling could be seen as the man who’s telling people below him that it’s okay to put up the power. Consequently, the traders kept manipulating the electricity market without asking ‘why?’ enough. Or, as a former Enron trader said in the documentary: “I just didn’t want confirmed what I suspected might be true, that what I was doing was in fact unethical, if not worse.”


Based on
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/1972574.stm
and the documentary 'Enron: The Smartest Guys In The Room'

The California Energy Crisis (1)


Back in December 2001, California suffered from two rolling blackouts, which means that there was not enough electricity for America’s largest state. Accordingly, electricity prices shot through the roof, in some cases by a factor of ten.
How could this possibly happen and more important, who was responsible for this energy crisis?

It all started with the deregulation of the electricity market in California a few years earlier. Thanks to the complicated and hard-to-follow new rules, a few smart guys inside Enron, such as Tim Belden, found plenty of loopholes to exploit the California energy system.

Basically, the Enron energy traders followed two massively effective strategies to make money out of ‘those poor grandmothers in California’ (sic). First, the traders created artificial electricity shortages by shutting down power plants. In energy shortage, they exported power out of the state. When prices soared again, the traders brought it back in.

However, the real money was made by arbitrage, essentially by betting that electricity prices would go up. As a result, the Enron traders made billions of dollars for the company, while the State of California was being plundered. The whole California electrical system, built a hundred years ago by Edison, was all of a sudden turned into a casino...


Based on the documentary 'Enron: The Smartest Guys In The Room'

zondag 5 december 2010

Enron: The smartest guys in the room

When people are confronted with the Enron scandal, they spontaneously think of numbers and complicated transactions. But in reality, the story of Enron is more like a human tragedy. It’s a story about humans and their flaws, such as arrogance, intolerance, and greed.

The documentary 'Enron: The Smartest Guys In The Room' gives us a profound insight into the different backgrounds of the three protagonists in the Enron saga: Lay, Skilling and Fastow.

First of all, there's Kenneth ‘Ken’ Lay, son of a Baptist preacher, who tries to leave his poor childhood behind and has the ambition to make huge wealth for himself. The deregulation of the energy market became his first mission. He succeeded and founded Enron back in 1985, which he would leave in 2001 with 300 million dollars cashed in over the years.

Next, we meet Jeffrey ‘Jeff’ Skilling, a nerdy financial whizz-kid, who has a very Darwinian view of how the world works. When he applied for Harvard Business School, a professor posed him the question “Are you smart?”. His response was: “I’m fucking smart”. Skilling was the self-declared genius who came up with the idea that energy could be traded like stocks and bonds.

Finally, there's Andy Fastow, the clever guy who developed a bunch of dummy accounts to essentially keep up the profits. Andy is an eloquent speaker, a man who uses his charm and salesmanship to convince companies to invest in his fake accounting constructions.

Despite all these skills, the story of Enron ended like a Greek drama. Lay, Skilling, Fastow and other smart guys thought that they were changing the world. Eventually, they all became victims of their own hubris.


Based on the documentary 'Enron: The Smartest Guys In The Room'

woensdag 17 november 2010

“The rich get richer, the poor get poorer”

The city of Houston, and its people, suffered a lot from the Enron scandal. The story of the Enron collapse and its consequences is a story about two different groups, causing two different reactions.

On the one hand, there’s a massive group of -relatively- poor, hard-working employees, who lost a lot of money, pension and savings. They do have plenty of negative feelings, such as anger and frustration, about the Enron scandal and are mostly in a struggle to survive financially.

On the other hand, there are certain former Enron executives, who caught some midnight bonuses just after Enron got bankrupt. Ken Lay for instance, former Enron chief, stayed
-relatively- wealthy in the years after the bankruptcy, and still believes he’s innocent.

Homo homini lupus. A man is a wolf to his fellow man. The story of Enron is one of greed and moral decline. The idea of corporate governance is a modest step forward, although I do believe that there will always be people in charge with too much ambition and greed inside them. Therefore, I think this could happen again... but not on such a gigantic scale anymore.


Based on http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4652322.stm